All Too Well一幀幀細膩生動的場景描寫,身臨其境的倒敘手法,從回憶起兩人依偎著開車時"You almost ran the red cause you were looking over at me",在家中廚房跳舞"We"re dancing "round the kitchen in the refrigerator light",到後來在電話中分手"You call me up again just to break me like a promise, so casually cruel in the name of being honest",再及後來想要釋然卻仍然放不下的"I"d like to be my old self again, but I"m still trying to find it",整首歌被她在結構上精心設計成一幕微電影,加以她一直以來捕捉感情變化捕捉片段場景的能力以及能用最簡單的詞彙表述最形象事物的能力,還有用"scarf"非常自然貼切地使歌曲首尾相應等小細節,說All Too Well是泰勒絲生涯斷層詞作TOP1也不為過。
另一首我認為詞作最出眾的是State Of Grace,這首歌是泰勒絲在20歲前後對愛情最深刻的思考,也是她對自己前幾次戀愛經歷總結內省得出來的經驗。"Love is a ruthless game unless you play it good and right"作為Red整張專輯的主旨句非常合宜。同時這也是泰勒絲最不泰勒絲的一首歌,全曲的描寫散亂跳脫,沒有常見的固定男性敘述物件,卻把現代生活中普遍的男女在愛情中的糾纏慌亂焦慮期望刻畫得淋漓盡致。
除此之外,22的"We"re happy free confused "nd lonely in the best way"對比精妙又有趣,還非常貼切;The Lucky One將前輩的星途和自己即將閃耀的前程類比,也是泰勒絲歌曲中非常罕見的主題:對於明星職業生涯的思索;Begin Again中"Thinkin" all love ever does is break, and burnx and end. But on a Wednesday in a cafe, I watched it begin again"是溫柔到讓人姨媽笑的對於生活和愛情的希望重燃;Holy Ground中"Never looking down. Cause right there where we stood is holy ground"是被愛情的甜蜜與幸福迷到不顧一切。只想橫衝直撞與他天長地久的最真實想法:別回頭,你在的地方,就是我的聖地。
還有I Knew You Were Trouble., Red, Starlight, Come Back Be Here等等眾多作詞優秀的歌曲,可以自己發掘其中漂亮/受用/感慨萬千的句子……
2.Red是泰勒絲在曲風選擇上最多元、最有實驗性的專輯。
State Of Grace和Holy Ground是另類搖滾,All Too Well是鄉村搖滾,Begin Again是鄉村,22是Teen Pop+Disco,We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together是流行,I Knew You Were Trouble.是Dubstep,Red是鄉村流行……
我認為是Red
1.Red的詞曲創作是我認為泰勒絲至今無法超越的斷層巔峰。
All Too Well一幀幀細膩生動的場景描寫,身臨其境的倒敘手法,從回憶起兩人依偎著開車時"You almost ran the red cause you were looking over at me",在家中廚房跳舞"We"re dancing "round the kitchen in the refrigerator light",到後來在電話中分手"You call me up again just to break me like a promise, so casually cruel in the name of being honest",再及後來想要釋然卻仍然放不下的"I"d like to be my old self again, but I"m still trying to find it",整首歌被她在結構上精心設計成一幕微電影,加以她一直以來捕捉感情變化捕捉片段場景的能力以及能用最簡單的詞彙表述最形象事物的能力,還有用"scarf"非常自然貼切地使歌曲首尾相應等小細節,說All Too Well是泰勒絲生涯斷層詞作TOP1也不為過。
另一首我認為詞作最出眾的是State Of Grace,這首歌是泰勒絲在20歲前後對愛情最深刻的思考,也是她對自己前幾次戀愛經歷總結內省得出來的經驗。"Love is a ruthless game unless you play it good and right"作為Red整張專輯的主旨句非常合宜。同時這也是泰勒絲最不泰勒絲的一首歌,全曲的描寫散亂跳脫,沒有常見的固定男性敘述物件,卻把現代生活中普遍的男女在愛情中的糾纏慌亂焦慮期望刻畫得淋漓盡致。
除此之外,22的"We"re happy free confused "nd lonely in the best way"對比精妙又有趣,還非常貼切;The Lucky One將前輩的星途和自己即將閃耀的前程類比,也是泰勒絲歌曲中非常罕見的主題:對於明星職業生涯的思索;Begin Again中"Thinkin" all love ever does is break, and burnx and end. But on a Wednesday in a cafe, I watched it begin again"是溫柔到讓人姨媽笑的對於生活和愛情的希望重燃;Holy Ground中"Never looking down. Cause right there where we stood is holy ground"是被愛情的甜蜜與幸福迷到不顧一切。只想橫衝直撞與他天長地久的最真實想法:別回頭,你在的地方,就是我的聖地。
還有I Knew You Were Trouble., Red, Starlight, Come Back Be Here等等眾多作詞優秀的歌曲,可以自己發掘其中漂亮/受用/感慨萬千的句子……
2.Red是泰勒絲在曲風選擇上最多元、最有實驗性的專輯。
State Of Grace和Holy Ground是另類搖滾,All Too Well是鄉村搖滾,Begin Again是鄉村,22是Teen Pop+Disco,We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together是流行,I Knew You Were Trouble.是Dubstep,Red是鄉村流行……
對比1989一水兒全在流行框架裡,最多從Synth Pop稍稍靠點Dance Pop,Red的曲風非常混雜。1989的好處是製作方便,氛圍感好,聽感統一不累,這些遠超Red,但Red的探索實驗與先鋒精神遠超1989。